The Philosophers' Cocoon

Pulling out of an unhappy fellowship?

In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I am beginning my second year in a clinical ethics fellowship. I am very unhappy with the program as I think I am not getting what I was promised. Moreover, I do not think that I really fit in with others in the department; something I have not yet experienced throughout my education, so it is quite jarring. During my first year, I gave several talks and published two articles and two commentaries. How bad would it look if I dropped out and went on the philosophy or medical ethics or health humanities markets this fall? Should I just stick it out for another 10 months? I don't know what to do. I have fairly substantial savings, so if I got some random job working at a grocery store or whatever, I wouldn't be too worried about money. Please help

Yikes, I'm sorry to hear this, but I guess I'm a bit uncertain what to advise. If you're deeply unhappy in a job or fellowship, then I think you have no obligation to continue on--but then again, assuming the fellowship is in the Northern Hemisphere, it seems to me pretty late to pull out of it at such a late date.

What do readers think?

Accepting one fellowship but leaving for another?

In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, BigBen asks:

Here is a hypothetical situation: you apply for more than one postdoctoral fellowships with proposals on distinct topics, get selected in one, and accept the offer. After you join, the other fellowship, which is way better than the first (e.g., gives you more freedom to conduct your own research without interference, provides funds for conference travel and to organize workshops, etc.) comes through.

What do you do? Do you simple leave the first one for the second one, which may mean that the employer may have to go through the whole process of recruiting again, or worse, they may not hire anyone else for the position? How much do the employer's feelings matter? Are there questions answerable?

Good questions, and I'll be curious to hear what everyone thinks. The general consensus on similar topics discussed here in the past (e.g., leaving one job for another) seems to have been that employers don't have any right to your employment, and it's fine to do what's best for one's career. Also, given that fellowships are temporary and the OP is presumably still after permanent academic employment, if the second fellowship seems more advantageous than the first in terms of flourishing in their career, then why not move?

But these are just a few quick thoughts. What are yours?

Center for AI Safety Fellowship

[T]he Center for AI Safety ... [is] a non-profit organization focused on research aimed at minimizing risks from advanced AI.

We’re hosting a fellowship program from January to August 2023 for students and graduates of philosophy PhD programs to work on AI safety. Fellows will have the opportunity to spend seven months in San Francisco writing and completing a research project, attending guest lectures (including talks given by Peter Railton, Shelly Kagan, and AI professors/research scientists at Berkeley, Cambridge, and DeepMind), participating in seminars, and working with other fellows and AI safety researchers.

No prior experience with AI is required.

Benefits:

• $60,000 grant for the seven-month program (willing to match competing offers)
• $20,000 housing stipend
• Full-time positions at the Center for AI Safety for top-performing fellows
• Connections to other institutions
• Free daily lunch and dinner
• Covered cost of travel

For the application and further information, you can find our website here: philosophy.safe.ai