Our books






Become a Fan

« Gregory Robson from Iowa State to Notre Dame | Main | Tips for a grad student writing a letter supporting a professor's promotion? »

03/20/2024

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Michel

One issue that I see is that generalist and specialist journals are jumbled together, including the journals for different specialties. (That's often an issue with "generalist" rankings, which include the likes of Ethics and PPA.)

I don't think it's true or useful to see Ethics ranked far above JHI; what's useful is for the ethicist or historian to have a sense of what the tiers are in their subfields. Or, rather, since most specialists will internalize their specialty rankings simply by dint of reading so much in those journals, it's useful for an outsider to know. But when they're all jumbled together, it's not very helpful.

Nick

PJIP has this disclaimer:

"The are many ways of evaluating philosophy journals. This page details some of the more common metrics...Importantly, the PJIP does not advocate for any particular way of ranking nor does the project assume to have any particular authority on the matter."

So, the default rankings on the site are based on every available metric. But if you think rankings should exclude some metrics (e.g., "CiteScore"), then you can do so and get rankings that reflect those exclusions.

I still think the Leiter rankings are the most reliable in terms of having a pulse on how many philosophers view journal rankings, which is most important for those using the rankings to ensure they're publishing in prestigious enough venues to secure career-advancements. But this is a nice alternative if you think other metrics should be doing the work.

Moral and political philosopher

Didn't know about this. It might be useful for comparing journals within an area, but not across different areas. The top 5 in e.g. moral and political philosophy is not unreasonable:

Journal of political philosophy
Ethics
PPA
Political theory
European journal of political theory

Andrew Richmond

Where are you seeing the overall ranking, with the different measures combined? I must be missing something — all I can find are rankings by each measure, separately.

Sam Andrews

Hi all, I run the PJIP journal site and just wanted to briefly clarify a few things.

Mainly that the index doesn't offer a 'new' or 'overall ranking' for journals. The index is just a collection of various rankings - when you load the page it is ordered by SJR by default. Due to the way it is set up, I had to pick one metric to order journals by, instead of say ordering alphabetically until a metric is selected by the user. I'll make some changes to the table so that it is easier to see which column is determining the ranking being presented.

There's another resource on the site that would probably be more useful for early career researchers: the PJIP Directory. It contains information about the area of publication, word counts, open access status, blind review policy, and types of papers published (book reviews; discussions) - see https://www.pjip.org/journal-directory.html

Also, the project isn't that new - an earlier version was posted on this site last year! (https://philosopherscocoon.typepad.com/blog/2023/06/philosophy-journal-insight-project.html) I intended to reach out again after running the Operations Survey (https://www.pjip.org/surveys.html) as that will fill in a lot of the blank spaces in the directory.

I'm happy to clarify any other ambiguities about the site/project!

Marcus Arvan

Hi Sam, thanks for clarifying! I'm a bit overwhelmed with things right now (including an infant at home), so I've been missing a few things here and there. I also have a terrible episodic memory, so it completely slipped my mind that we'd featured this before! ;)

Sam Andrews

Also, for Michel & Moral and political philosopher,
You can filter the table to show journals that only publish in a particular area of philosophy. See the area 'Filters' options at the top of the table. Selecting GRNL will only show generalist journals, M&P will only show moral and political, etc. (there is a key below for all abbreviations).

For Nick,
The Leiter rankings are included for generalist journals, - it's the column titled 'Leit'.

Hope that helps!
(and no worries Marcus, happy to clarify!)

sisyphus

OP here. Sorry, in rereading my original post I see that I gave the impression that PJIP gave a new ranking. Didn't intend to do that - should have reread what I wrote more closely before posting!(Also would have caught the grammatical error. I can sympathize with Marcus as I've got a toddler who divides my attention when doing this sort of stuff!) I merely meant to say that it gives a new side-by-side comparison of rankings. Sorry for any confusion!

And Sam, I've already benefited from all the aggregating work you've done when I was recently trying to find a venue that will accept certain word counts. Thanks!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Subscribe to the Cocoon

Job-market reporting thread

Current Job-Market Discussion Thread

Philosophers in Industry Directory

Categories

Subscribe to the Cocoon