In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:
Can I still get into top philosophy PhD programs after a break, following my MA?
I've always been a kind of all-or-nothing type of person, studying philosophy only at top international schools. Last year, after my MA from a well-known terminal program in the U.S., I tried for the top 10 (and only top 10) PhD programs and didn't get in, except for two waitlists that didn't work out. Now, I'm in a high-tech research/writing job, wondering if my chances for those elite PhD spots are already gone. I'm thinking of applying again in the future, but I'm not sure if there's any clear way of collecting more prestige to make my application matter to these schools. I have the option of making myself an American citizen in the next few years, which would matter I suppose, but the gap between my MA and applications is growing larger. Any advice?
I don't think a year off in industry is likely to negatively impact the OP's changes for getting into a top PhD program. How much time away from academia might? I'm not sure. But elite PhD programs are so selective that one's chances of getting in are tiny to begin with. In any case, another reader submitted the following reply:
what do you mean by top international schools: Cambridge and Oxford? Munich? NYU in Dubai? It makes a big difference to your answer.
The OP hasn't replied, but I'm curious what everyone thinks. Does anyone have any helpful insights?
I don't see why you would need to collect more prestige. I think your best bet would be to write a better writing sample, revise it based on expert feedback, and then reapply.
Posted by: Grad applicant | 01/09/2024 at 12:26 PM
I got into two top-10 PhD programs after working for 3 years after my standalone MA. My BA was from a non-prestigious university and my MA was from a highly ranked non-American school. I doubt prestige is your problem. I'd focus on the writing sample and maybe even publishing something from your MA if you have anything suitable. Other than that, all PhDs are a crapshoot so I wouldn't take your waitlists as anything other than bad luck. Try again and maybe cast your net wider than the top 10 this time.
Posted by: TT Prof Now | 01/09/2024 at 02:12 PM