In the comments section of my recent call for additional mentors for the Cocoon's Job-Market Mentoring Program, Amanda wrote:
I applied to over 60 jobs last year, both research and teaching, and very few (maybe 5) asked for research statements. I think that is becoming a thing of the past, and one is expected to say a few words about their research in their cover letter instead.
Can others confirm whether this is true? Are research statements becoming a thing of the past? If so, why?
Although I'm all for making the job-application process easier (and so am presumptively inclined to applaud this change, if indeed it is occurring!), I have to confess to being a bit surprised. Given that (at least in my experience) search committees tend to want a clear picture that one has a viable long-term research program (as tenure at most schools requires a substantial publishing record post-hire), I would have thought most search committees would think research statements important.
In any case, I'm curious whether this is a real trend, and if so, if anyone "in the know" could say a bit about why the change is occurring!
You sound very doubtful of me Marcus! But I would be happy to learn if I was just suppressing the horrible memory of all the research statements I don't remember submitting.
Posted by: Amanda | 07/11/2017 at 12:24 PM
No, not at all! Just surprised, really. ;) I was last on the market just a few years ago, and research statements were still standard then. It would very much help me to find out more as a job-market mentor. I'm also just curious about search-committees' rationale for no longer requiring them.
Posted by: Marcus Arvan | 07/11/2017 at 12:26 PM
This was my second year on the market, my first year was a soft search ABD. I noticed a big difference in just these two years. If I had to guess a reason some schools did away with the research statement, is probably just the work load. There are soooo many applicants!
Posted by: Amanda | 07/11/2017 at 12:35 PM
I applied to 70 or so this year, and 100 or so last year. I definitely sent my research statement to more than 5 each year, but still not to as many as I expected to send it to. I think that's mostly an artifact of the kinds of jobs out there, though. Postdocs ask for their own proposals, and VAPs and other temporary positions don't really need them. Most non-elite teaching institutions didn't seem to ask, either. It was pretty much just the universities with PhD programs, or fancy SLACs.
Posted by: Michel X. | 07/12/2017 at 09:11 AM
I applied to 90 jobs last year and submitted research statements about 25-30% of the time. I think Michel X. has it right: what's required for a job application depends in large part on what kind of institution and position you are applying for.
Posted by: Trevor Hedberg | 07/12/2017 at 10:32 AM
Trevor & Michel: Interesting. I don't recall things being like that was applying! Although my memory could be faulty, I recall having to submit research statements for just about every type of job.
Posted by: Marcus Arvan | 07/12/2017 at 10:59 AM
This was my experience this year as well. I applied to 70 positions and a large majority of them didn't ask for a research statement.
Posted by: Nate | 07/12/2017 at 11:05 AM
Picking up an old thread ... when I applied for jobs for the first time (about 8 years ago) I was told to include a dissertation summary (or research statement, once a year or two out) as the last page of the cv, if it's not asked for explicitly. Is that very idiosyncratic? Is it absolutely uncontroversial that, if no RS is requested, then one should give a substantial discussion of research in the cover letter (I am thinking just of research universities)? If so, can this part of the cover letter be a page or more? My research statement is two pages, e.g.. Thanks!
Posted by: Andrea | 11/12/2017 at 12:30 PM
I don't think there really is any standards, but I always included a longer cover letter when there was no research statement. And especially for research schools I would spend some time covering my future research plans. I also did include a page long abstract of my dissertation at the bottom of my CV. I figured that is easy to ignore if the search committee is not interested.
Posted by: Amanda | 11/12/2017 at 05:34 PM
I would add that putting the entire 2-page research statement into a cover letter is probably too much. I would cut it down to a page.
Posted by: Amanda | 11/12/2017 at 05:35 PM
Hi Amanda, thanks for your answer. I'm surprised that there aren't standards (or clear guidelines in ads), given that we philosophers like being precise. I guess I will try to put about a page of research stuff in the letter.
Posted by: Andrea | 11/15/2017 at 01:16 PM
clear guidelines in all the ads ...
Posted by: Andrea | 11/15/2017 at 01:22 PM