« New Contributor: Shane Ralston | Main | Open Access & Self-Archiving »

10/04/2012

Comments

Marcus Arvan

David: count me in! Sounds like a great opportunity for students.

David Killoren

Thanks, Marcus! It will be great to have you on board.

elisa freschi

This is a very interesting idea. May I ask you how you will make it into a "conference"? In other words, each presenter will get the feedback of his or her commentator and of people who might watch his/her video and read his/her paper? Or are all the other participants invited/forced to read the other papers? (I would recommend the latter option). I am going to drop you a line in case you need a further commentator.

David Killoren

Thanks, Elisa! It will be great to have you involved in this project (especially given that you have expertise in some areas of Philosophy that are too often neglected in some circles).

The basic set-up is this: Each presenter will present her paper via video, and each presenter will be assigned a commentator, who will deliver her comments via video. These videos will be made available on the conference website. There will also be a comments section associated with each presentation/commentary, so that conference participants (i.e., viewers) can ask questions of the presenter and/or commentator, and can engage in discussion with one another (via text). (The conference website will not go live until the Spring semester; we're in the process of building it now.)

elisa freschi

I have experienced something like that only once and part of the problem was the fact that ---knowing that the videos would have been online forever--- one did not really take the time to engage simultaneously. Comments were quite apart from each other and this is frustrating for the presenters, since they feel their work will need re-working endlessly. How will you deal with that? Perhaps announcing a "conference date" during which the presenters will be online and commit themselves to answer as soon as possible to all comments they might receive?

David Killoren

Many thanks for sharing your ideas and experience, Elisa. Yes, the conference will have official start and end dates. During that span of time, all of the conference presentations will be posted. (The length of the conference will be perhaps 7-14 days--this will depend partly on the number of papers that we accept for the main program.) We will ask presenters and commenters to be available to respond to questions and comments during that period. Once the conference is over, we might want to close the comment boxes.

elisa freschi

Thanks a lot for answering! I look forward to see how it works!

Richard Brown

Great idea David! I wrote my diss in metaethics (even though I don't really work in that area any more) and I would be happy to be a commenter should you have the need.

David Killoren

Many thanks, Richard! It'll be awesome to have you involved--especially since you've already demonstrated that you're good on video!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.